I really want to like this shoe. It has a classy look and vibe but is constructed for comfort ... but I had to return it.First, check out the photo ... all three of these shoes are a size 9 (42), and this shoe ran considerably large. I would order a half size smaller, but they only make 8 and 9, and I don't want to take the change that the 8 is too small.Second, the material around the toes was tight and stiff and made the first wear uncomfortable. This is typical of a new shoe, and I would hope that with time, this would wear in and get comfortable. I didn't get the change to put that to the test.Overall, I like the shoe. I bought it during Prime day at a discount, which made it even a better value. I would buy it again, if they made an 8.5 size.