Definitely tight! I have a handful of Frye shoes and boots. These wrecked my feet until broken in, but they look and feel great after a couple of painful weeks.Great for the most part but stitches does like little when you do not wear socks.Excellent seller, fast Transaction, smoothly deal, high quality, good price, i recommendLove these shoes. Well made. Much cheaper for he reddish brown version vs the brown leather. Just as nice.Great shoe, fits as stated and comfortable to walk around in. Also great to get it at a fantastic price and with Prime the free shipping.Fit is tight at first but eventually streachs to size. Great shoes!I tried two different sizes, but very tight and the top of shoes pushing down my top of archer badly when walking around.Perfect.Very poor quality. Shoe is falling apart. I expected better from Frye.Well made and what I expected. The only area where I could see any improvement at all is a slightly more cushy insole.